Saturday, 4 September 2004: Otley 37 Orrell 28

Saturday, 11 September 2004: Nottingham 25 Otley 38

Saturday, 18 September 2004: Otley 6 Bedford Blues 34

Saturday, 25 September 2004: Sedgley Park 8 Otley 28

Saturday, 2 October 2004: Pertemps Bees 32 Otley 19

Saturday, 9 October 2004: Otley 15 Henley Hawks 9

Saturday, 16 October 2004: Bracknell 27 Otley 31 [Powergen Cup R3]

Saturday, 23 October 2004: Otley 24 Penzance & Newlyn Pirates 13

Saturday, 6 November 2004: Otley 45 Westcombe Park 16 [Powergen Cup R4]

Saturday, 13 November 2004: Coventry 27 Otley 26

Saturday, 20 November 2004: Otley 24 London Welsh 3

Saturday, 27 November 2004: Plymouth Albion 23 Otley 15 [Powergen Cup R5]

Saturday, 4 December 2004: Plymouth Albion 11 Otley 11

Sunday, 12 December 2004: Bristol Shoguns 23 Otley 11

Monday, 27 December 2004: Otley 24 Rotherham 12

Monday, 3 January 2005: Orrell 19 Otley 38

Saturday, 8 January 2005: Otley 37 Nottingham 5

Saturday, 15 January 2005: Bedford Blues 26 Otley 13

Saturday, 22 January 2005: Otley 36 Sedgley Park 3

Saturday, 29 January 2005: Otley 17 Pertemps Bees 6

Saturday, 19 February 2005: Henley Hawks 12 Otley 13

Saturday, 26 February 2005: Penzance & Newlyn Pirates 17 Otley 20

Saturday, 5 March 2005: Exeter Chiefs 41 Otley 15

Saturday, 12 March 2005: Otley 27 Exeter Chiefs 7

Saturday, 26 March 2005: Rotherham 6 Otley 26

Saturday, 2 April 2005: Otley 17 Coventry 16

Saturday, 9 April 2005: London Welsh 20 Otley 14

Saturday, 23 April 2005: Otley 24 Plymouth Albion 17

Saturday, 30 April 2005: Otley 13 Bristol Shoguns 16